Top

Heal the Bay Blog

Author: Heal the Bay

Water is the driving force in nature.” – Leonardo Da Vinci

Tomorrow we celebrate the global importance of clean, fresh water as part of World Water Day. In most of the world, people don’t have access to safe drinking water, while here in Los Angeles protecting our water remains an ongoing challenge.

Which is why we are so grateful to our partners and friends who support our work to maintain a locally sustainable water supply and to protect what we all love and value—clean water!

Just this Tuesday we hosted a workshop focused on the Malibu Creek Watershed and our work to understand this vast clean water resource in our own backyard. We’d like to thank our partners who came out that evening to share their expertise about animals and native plants, scenic hiking spots and restoration activities in the area: Santa Monica Bay Restoration Foundation, Mountains Restoration Trust, Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area, LA Waterkeeper, California Wildlife Center, Malibu Creek State Park Docents, and California Native Plant Society.

We are also thankful to the 715 volunteers who joined us to pick up 371 pounds of trash at Nothin’ But Sand last Saturday at Venice Pier. Plus, as part of our ongoing Zero Waste initiative, we only used a handful of plastic bags, as most folks either brought their own buckets, or borrowed one of ours! A special shout out to Jason Holland and the Credit Suisse team, whose volunteer hours translated into donation dollars, ensuring that our effective pollution prevention programs such as Nothin’ But Sand keep running and keep our local waters clean.

We’d also like to thank Canehill Glass Ranch for donating to our clean water cause, including lovely repurposed glass “thank you items” to some of our top supporters.

Do you value clean water? Learn more about our work to maintain a healthy local water supply .

Join us on Earth Day (April 20) for our next Nothin’ But Sand cleanup.

Malibu Creek Watershed: Ecosystem on the Brink



A single storm can sweep billions of gallons of polluted runoff directly into Santa Monica Bay.  Yes, that’s billions with a “B.”  So it’s not much of a stretch to understand why the majority of waterbodies in Los Angeles County, including the Santa Monica Bay, are officially impaired by bacteria, trash and metals. In fact, 7 of the 10 most polluted beaches in California are located right here in our backyard.

Equally troubling, valuable storm water is literally going down the drain.  We live in in an area of permanent drought, yet we keep building and expanding, importing billions of gallons of costly and increasingly scarce water from our neighbors to fuel our growing demand. Imagine if we captured and reused the water from storms instead of funneling water into stormdrains and rivers and to be dumped full of pollution into the sea?

Take Action

Storm water, if recharged, can provide a safe and less expensive source of water.  Rainwater becomes an asset, rather than a liability.

Last week, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors considered moving forward with the “Clean Water, Clean Beaches” Measure, a funding measure that would help local cities and the County implement critical clean water projects to protect our region’s surface waters and also provide other added benefits such as increasing the local water supply and open space. Property owners would be assessed an annual fee based on the amount of runoff their parcels generate. The typical homeowner would pay roughly $54 a year.

The measure has been contemplated for the past seven years but gained momentum over the last year, as new storm water regulations were recently adopted.

A diverse mix of supporters – including representatives from local cities, businesses, environmental organizations and community groups from across L.A. County came out to support the Measure. The supporters outnumbered the protestors, despite the hearing being a “protest hearing” specifically required by law to consider opposition to the measure.

We are grateful that so many supporters showed up to make their voices heard, but it was especially gratifying to see middle school students from the Santa Monica Alternative Schoolhouse, who took the Santa Monica Blue Bus to the hearing, testifying as well as absorbing a valuable lesson in how our local government functions.

Some critics complained about how the outreach materials were assembled and distributed to the public. On principle, others opposed the idea of any more levies on property owners to fund public works infrastructure and programs, no matter the need.

While there was some positive discussion by the Supervisors about needing to clean up our region’s waterways, they did not all see the urgency in moving the measure forward expeditiously, despite three board members of the Regional Quality Control Board testifying in support of the measure and referencing looming compliance deadlines.

At times it felt like the supervisors wanted a silver-bullet solution to their water quality issues to avoid enforcement. Simply implementing a project or policy doesn’t mean that sufficient water quality improvement will result.   Several supervisors were disturbingly misinformed about their legal responsibilities to implement Clean Water Act requirements.

Instead, the approved motion contemplates a general election with a “goal” of 2014.  This direction deviates from the previous trajectory of presenting a mail ballot this spring to property owners, which seems fair given that they are the individuals most directly affected by the fee. Keep in mind, that 2/3 of voters are needed to pass a fee-related measure in a general election – a very high bar to meet — rather than a simple majority for a property owners ballot.  Some see the change as a significant setback for the measure, especially because a property owner ballot is a completely viable option.  However, stormwater advocates need to remain positive and vigilant.  

So what is next?

We will continue to work with the County to ensure that the content of the measure is as strong as possible. It’s almost there but just needs a little more work. The measure should include a refined rebate and incentive program for property owners who are already implementing stormwater capture practices. Parties are also debating the exact nature of a so-called sunset clause, which determines a phase-out period for the fees. With a report due back to the supervisors in 90 days, remaining issues should be hammered out by then.

Hopefully, the Regional Water Quality Control Board and staff responsible for implementing water quality requirements in cities and L.A. County can educate their elected officials about water quality requirements and the many consequences of not having the necessary funding to implement infrastructure enhancements.  There is an alarming disconnect here.

Concurrently, we need to strategize on additional paths forward to achieve a sustainable funding source for water quality improvement projects. The consequences of not doing anything are very dire. Not only will the benefits such as improved water quality, public health protection, job creation and increased local water supply not be realized, but municipalities will not be afforded this important source of funding for achieving compliance with mandatory Clean Water Act requirements.

Do you support a sustainable approach to clean water? Contact your Los Angeles County supervisor to support the “Clean Water, Clean Beaches” measure!



With St. Patrick’s Day on Sunday, we’d like to thank those of you who help us “green” Los Angeles and our planet. It’s gratifying to know we’re in this together!

Thank you to the Santa Monica City Council for unanimously voting to support the Earth with the Santa Monica Sustainability Bill of Rights. The law recognizes that “residents of Santa Monica possess fundamental and inalienable rights to: clean water from sustainable sources; marine waters safe for active and passive recreation….”

We’d also like to thank the staff at the Mayme Clayton Library in Culver City for hosting our Earth Month Youth Summit. Students from six local schools, including groups from Dorsey and Crenshaw high schools, came out last Saturday to learn about “greening” their campuses and communities. Big thanks to Alison Jefferson, Rick Blocker and Rusty White who came to the summit to discuss the documentary White Wash, which chronicles the history of black surfing.

Special thanks go to Patagonia’s Santa Monica store, which recently awarded us a grant to help sustain our marine debris work.

Also, a “green” Thank You Thursday would be incomplete without green crayons! Thanks to California Pizza Kitchen on Wilshire Boulevard for donating green crayons (and other colors too) for visitors to our Santa Monica Pier Aquarium. (Heal the Bay’s Aquarium staff would also like to thank CPK for feeding them a delicious lunch last week.)

Meanwhile, we’d also like to thank Golden Road for donating libations to our Tank event at the Aquarium a few weeks ago. We look forward to working with you to “green” L.A. in the coming months.

Go “green” this weekend by volunteering with our monthly cleanup Nothin’ But Sand.



Cool clear water cascades softly above glistening rocks, as a California newt munches on some caddisfly larvae. Brilliant Humboldt lilies peek over the earthen creek bank, where a California chorus frog hopes to catch an unsuspecting eight-legged meal. Hard to believe that just a short distance downstream, we are confronted with the effects of man-made barriers and pollution as well as non-native plants and animals in Malibu Creek.

Heal the Bay’s Stream Team has collected data from the Malibu Creek Watershed for 12 years and compiled their findings into our first comprehensive report: Malibu Creek Watershed: An Ecosystem on the Brink. Heal the Bay has identified three key problems facing the watershed and offered solutions for each, but despite the degradation and deterioration, we also discovered three hidden gems in the Malibu Creek Watershed:

Hiking the Cold Creek Lower Stunt High Trail. One of the most pristine spots in the watershed and plenty of shade to escape a hot day. Keep your eyes peeled for native amphibians, such as California newts and Pacific and California chorus frogs. To access the Cold Creek trail, travel approximately 1 mile on Stunt Rd. from Mulholland Highway. Park at the lot and hike down to Cold Creek.

Visiting Malibu Creek State Park Rock Pool. A fine spot to picnic, rock climb or swim (although we encourage swimmers to take precaution, and avoid ingesting the water or swimming when you have an open wound). We are working with State Parks to notify swimmers about poor water quality in Malibu Creek State Park. (Malibu Creek State Park, 2028 Las Virgenes Rd., Calabasas, CA 91302)

Taking a scenic drive from Malibu Creek State Park to Kanan Rd. along Mulholland Highway, ending at Rustic Canyon General Store & Grill for a bite to eat (the onion rings are yummy!).

Read more about Heal the Bay’s findings on the Malibu Creek Watershed.

Join us March 19 for “State of the Malibu Creek Watershed” public workshop and discussion.



The city of Santa Monica is bustling with development projects, and the area around our Santa Monica Pier Aquarium is at the hub of construction activity. We’re committed to providing updates on construction and links to websites that map the best routes and point out parking availability. Most importantly, please remember the Aquarium and the Pier are open! These links will help you get to the Aquarium — our sea urchins still need hugs.

More: Visitor Information for reaching the Santa Monica Pier Aquarium. Still have questions? Call the Aquarium at 310-393-6149.



Sarah Sikich, Heal the Bay’s director of coastal resources and Dana Roeber Murray, Heal the Bay marine scientist, recently attended a conference in Monterey that examined how well marine protected areas are functioning off California’s coast. Heal the Bay has played a critical role in establishing MPAs in Southern California. Here Sarah shares lessons learned at the symposium.

“Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It’s not.”

As to many conservationists, this quote from Dr. Seuss’ The Lorax has meant a lot to me throughout my life and career. It was inspiring to hear Chuck Bonham, the Director of California Department of Fish and Wildlife, conclude his remarks at the State of the Central Coast MPA Symposium with this quote last Friday. (Maybe he was channeling Theodor Seuss Geisel, as it was Dr. Seuss’ birthday the following day, March 2!)

Spending a few days in Monterey with Dana Murray, Heal the Bay’s Marine and Coastal Scientist, listening to resource managers, policy makers, stakeholders, and scientists reflect on the first five years of marine protected area (MPA) monitoring and management along California’s Central Coast gave me hope for restoring Southern California’s marine resources, with our own MPAs on the South Coast going into effect last year. It was an intense three days in a room with over 350 people, but we both learned a lot about how the Central Coast MPAs (from Pigeon Point to Point Conception) are functioning.

These “lessons learned” may give us insights on other MPAs up and down the coast will perform, as the Central Coast has the first coastal MPA network to be implemented in California.

Here are the top three snapshots that Dana and I took away from the symposium.

1. The early signs are encouraging

The overall trend in marine life growth and abundance is positive! While there is some variation between species and MPAs, many fish, including blue rockfish, lingcod, and cabezon are more abundant inside the MPAs as compared to outside these areas. Research also shows that some species, including black abalone and owl limpets are larger in the MPAs. In one of the oldest underwater parks along California’s coast, Point Lobos (a 40-year old marine reserve), scientists documented more fish and larger fish- and similar results are starting to be seen in some of the newer MPAs. With a robust network of underwater parks throughout the state now in place, hopefully we will start to see similar trends in other locations, including Southern California.

Commercial and recreational fishing and other commercial ventures are also showing improvement. Overall commercial fishing revenue has increased since MPA implementation, and recreational fishermen’s total catch has actually increased. In addition, people are adapting to public demands for recreation– some former fishing boats have moved on to provide non-consumptive ventures such as whale watching.

2. Community-based research helps provide insights

As a group that relies on volunteer engagement and stewardship to reach wide audiences and conduct research, Heal the Bay recognizes great value in citizen science. It was motivating to see how important community-based research and citizen science is in evaluating the Central Coast MPAs. A broad range of groups are involved in these efforts– volunteer SCUBA divers surveying marine life with Reef Check, fishermen working with marine ecologists to assess population trends like the California Collaborative Fisheries Research Program, high school students monitoring tidepools through the LiMPETS program, and volunteers monitoring human uses in MPAs through the Otter Project’s MPA Watch program. These programs offer many benefits beyond data collection – they are cost-effective, build awareness, create community trust and transparency in the research, and promote stewardship among participants. This provides promise for Heal the Bay’s research programs that rely on volunteer scientists, like Stream Team and MPA Watch.

3. People still care about MPAs

It’s no secret that the MPA designation and adoption process was contentious, and a challenge to balance various interests in creating these new underwater parks. So, it was exciting to see the conference room packed with hundreds of people from throughout the state during all three days of the symposium – it is clear that people are eager to learn about the research findings, and there was a general buzz of positivity in the room.

Another sign that people are caring for our MPAs comes from the trends of public calls to Cal-TIP, presented at the symposium by Assistant Chief Bob Farrell of Fish & Wildlife’s Marine Division. Cal-TIP is a confidential call-in line for the public to Fish and Wildlife to report illegal activities of poaching and polluting, in an effort to help protect the state’s biological resources. In 2012, 259 calls came in from the public reporting violations in California’s MPAs via 1 888 DFG-CALTIP (888 334-2258). Public reporting is a form of community stewardship of our oceans, as it helps both our natural resources and Fish and Wildlife’s enforcement efforts. Although education efforts are key to the success of MPAs, reporting violations to Fish and Wildlife is imperative as well- Farrell stated that “poaching activity directly affects the recovery and rebuilding rates of an area.”

People care about these special places, and are working together in creative ways to build “social capital” or awareness and stewardship about these MPAs. I guess this shouldn’t be a surprise, as one of our most popular volunteer programs, MPA Watch, involves monitoring underwater parks in our region.

Another gem from Chuck Bonham closed the symposium- that California has created “an MPA network that rivals none other in the world.” MPA creation in California has been a true collaborative process, which will hopefully provide long-lasting benefits California’s coastal environment and its ocean users.

Find out more about the Central Coast MPAs.

Watch highlights from the State of the California Central Coast symposium on February 28, 2013.

Want to get involved with monitoring and research in Southern California? Sign up for Heal the Bay’s volunteer scientist programs Stream Team and MPA Watch.

— Sarah Sikich, Heal the Bay’s Coastal Resources Director



UPDATE 3/8/2013: After hours of public comment and following decades of the Navy dismissing mitigation requirements for sonar and explosion practices, the Coastal Commission unanimously voted to reject the Navy’s consistency permit! Read the full update here.

The U.S. Navy plans to conduct large-scale naval training exercises involving intense mid-frequency sonar pulses and explosives off the California coast from Orange County to San Diego, extending more than 600 nautical miles out to sea for another five years from 2014 to 2019.

The Southern California coast is home to an estimated 34 species of marine mammals, and the impacts of the training activities are particularly threatening to around 20 of these species because of their endangered status or higher predicted sensitivity to noise. While activities will be concentrated in this area of Southern California, impacts could extend out of the range of activity due to the intensity of the sonar and because dolphins and whales are wide-ranging, so the same animals we see here in the Bay may be directly impacted. The Navy’s planned activities will result in more than 9.5 million instances of harm to whales and dolphins – including nearly 2,000 instances of permanent hearing loss or other permanent injury and more than 150 deaths.

Whales and other marine mammals rely on their hearing for orientation and communication- to find food, companions, a mate, and their way through the ocean. Sounds that are thousands of times more powerful than a jet engine, such as those that would result from the proposed activity, can be devastating, and deadly. Man-made sound waves, or acoustic pollution, can drown out the noises that marine mammals rely on for their very survival, causing serious injury and even death. For more information on the impacts of sonar, go to NRDC’s website. In addition, numerous mass strandings and whale deaths across the globe have been linked to military sonar use. According to scientists, dolphins are projected to be the most impacted species, followed by whales and orcas.

Before these training exercises can begin, the Navy must ask the California Coastal Commission to determine that these activities are consistent with California’s Coastal Management Program. Conducting sonar activities more than 9.5 million times that will harm marine mammals without taking adequate steps to significantly reduce the amount of harm to these and other coastal resources cannot be consistent with California’s Coastal Management Program- whose goal is to protect, preserve, and enhance our coastal environment.

The last time the Navy came before the Commission, the Commission found that these training exercises could only be found consistent if the Navy implemented a set of measures to reduce harm to marine mammals. The Navy refused to comply with the Commission’s recommendations and conducted its training exercises without implementing the measures designed to protect California’s marine resources. Stranded whales are the most visible symptom of the deadly impacts of sonar- over the past 40 years, cumulative research across the globe has revealed a correlation between naval sonar activities and decompression sickness in beached marine mammals. Many of these beached whales show evidence of suffering from physical trauma, including bleeding around the brain, ears and other tissues, and large bubbles in their organs. Scientists believe that the Navy’s sonar blasts may drive whales and dolphins to change their dive patterns- surfacing too quickly, resulting in decompression sickness.

The Navy is poised to do the same thing again. We must bolster the resolve of the Commission and ensure that it continues to stand up to the Navy. Please help us tell the California Coastal Commission that the Navy must do more to protect our coastal resources.

Background materials on the Navy’s Sonar and Munitions Program and the Coastal Commission can be found here.



How did weeds get to Southern California? One of the principal causes of habitat destruction, weeds threaten our region’s natural places.  Constant maintenance and eradication is an absolute necessity as we battle against exotic invasive plants, and it’s beneficial to understand the origins of this enemy.

Weeds are here because people brought them here, sometimes deliberately, sometimes accidentally. Some were brought long ago, some only recently, but whatever the reason we have no one to blame but ourselves.

A common example is black mustard. Originally from Europe and one of the most widespread and recognizable weeds in California, it was supposedly scattered by Franciscan padres to mark the route of El Camino Real (which means it’s been here at least 300 years). The story is probably true, but it’s likely the missionaries also cultivated mustard for its food and medicinal properties, which is a common reason for the presence of many weeds.

Many common weeds in the Santa Monicas were likely introduced deliberately to the U.S. by European immigrants: mustards, horehound, milk thistle, fennel, common plantain (goose tongue), cheeseweed, castor bean, watercress… the list goes on. Some weeds have been brought accidentally, mixed in with the seed of a cultivated food crop, say perennial pepperweed contaminating sugar beet seeds or something. Others were brought as food for imported animals; red-stemmed filaree was likely brought as a forage plant for the livestock immigrants were importing. All in all the transportation of food, forage, and medicinal crops, seed, and plants is probably the most prevalent explanation for the presence of weeds.

But then we also brought a lot of them over because we liked the look of them or found them useful in some way. Eucalyptus trees are from Australia and they’re invasive, some species more than others. They were planted all over California from the late 1800s to the 1930s as a cash crop and also because we simply thought they were cool ornamentals.

Chinese immigrants brought Tree of Heaven here around the same time also as a fast-growing ornamental.  Iceplant was planted for decades for erosion control along roadways and on beaches. It’s common along the entirety of California’s coast but is originally from South Africa.

There’s also money in weeds, at least for a time, as plenty of invasives were introduced by the nursery industry. Here in California common selling points for non-native plants that end up becoming invasive would be things like “erosion control,” “drought resistance,” and “fast growing.” Fountain grass is a terrible invasive (fast growing and drought resistant!), responsible for untold millions of dollars’ worth of habitat degradation and destruction, and incredibly still sold by some nurseries.

Same with pampas grass. Very pretty and striking, very destructive, and still sold by some nurseries. Mexican feather grass is a new ornamental grass gaining popularity and though it hasn’t been around long enough to become and invasive, it’s “fast growing” and “drought resistant” properties coupled with the ability to reseed itself means it’s probably just a matter of time until it’s a problem, too. Rule of thumb: if it’s “fast growing” and “drought tolerant” but not a native, skip it.

Because of growing awareness there’s generally less deliberate and accidental introduction of invasives today than in the past when we, A) didn’t understand how invasives would be a problem and, B) really seemed to enjoy nothing more than mowing down native flora and spreading pretty exotics everywhere. However the world is incredibly interconnected and there are people and animals and ships and planes crisscrossing the world every day, so we’re probably going to keep on having new, awful problems to deal with.

As a concerned citizen, here’s what you can do:

Next time, we’ll introduce you to specific weeds, where they’re a problem, and what we’re trying to do about it.

Feel like getting a good workout and fighting weeds at the same time? Join our restoration this weekend in Malibu Creek State Park on Sunday, March 10.



 “The tipping point is that magic moment when an idea, trend, or social behavior crosses a threshold, tips, and spreads like wildfire.”

― Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference

We know that billions of single-use plastic bags are used in Los Angeles every year, and that the majority of single-use plastic bags – even if reused once or twice by consumers – end up in our landfills or as part of the litter stream, polluting our inland and coastal communities and wasting taxpayer dollars on cleanup costs.

Los Angeles, we are at a tipping point when it comes to tackling the scourge of plastic bag pollution.

On May 23, 2012, the Los Angeles City Council voted to move forward with drafting an ordinance that would ban single-use plastic bags and place a charge on paper bags at grocery stores and select other retailers throughout the City. The Bureau of Sanitation recently released its draft Environmental Impact Report (PDF) for public review and comment; comments are due on March 11, 2013. It is our hope that the City Council will vote on the ordinance later this spring.

If adopted, Los Angeles will be the largest city in the United States to approve a single-use bag ordinance, and its passage will send a clear message to the rest of the state (and country) that addressing plastic bag waste (and by implication, our disposable consumer culture) is an idea whose time has come.

In fact, once passed, Los Angeles will join the company of 65 California counties and cities that have banned plastic bags, including many jurisdictions in SoCal. And by the looks of it, that number is set to grow; City Councils in Sacramento, Culver City and Huntington Beach, among others, are currently engaged in discussions about whether to enact their own single-use bag ordinances. The idea of reducing the economic waste and environmental impacts associated with single-use bag litter has even spread to the California statehouse where State Senator Alex Padilla (D-Pacoima) and State Assembly Member Marc Levine (D-San Rafael) have introduced bag bills.

But first we have to reach the tipping point by passing the Los Angeles bag ordinance. Stay tuned for more information about the City Council’s final vote later this spring and how you can get involved! Follow us on Twitter to stay-up-to-date.

Want to help reduce marine debris? Join one of our cleanups!

Stay engaged with Heal the Bay as we head toward the finish line in Los Angeles.



On May 16, Heal the Bay honors three supporters who’ve lent their formidable voices to protecting the ocean from plastic pollution at our annual benefit gala Bring Back the Beach.

In 2010, Oscar-winner Jeremy Irons narrated our mockumentary The Majestic Plastic Bag, lending gravitas to the story of a single-use plastic bag as it migrates to the Great Pacific Garbage Patch. The film screened at the Sundance film festival and remains popular on the film festival circuit. To date, The Majestic Plastic Bag has been viewed more than 1.8 million times on Heal the Bay’s YouTube channel.

We honor Jeremy Irons, not merely for sharing his rich, haunting voice with us, but for his ongoing work to stop the proliferation of trash. In his new feature documentary “Trashed: No Place for Waste,” Irons takes a different journey, this one following the migration of rubbish, the tons of waste that goes unaccounted for each year. Irons serves as the film’s chief investigator as well as the executive producer.

Heal the Bay will also honor our longtime champion Mark Gold for his years of laser-like focus and tireless advocacy in support of clean water. Mark was Heal the Bay’s first employee and served with our organization for 25 years, leading and inspiring our work as our executive director and president. He continues to support us as a researcher, fundraiser and board member. We can count on Mark as a sounding board, resource and guiding force as we tackle future attacks on clean water.

Philanthropist Dr. Howard Murad will be honored on May 16 for raising awareness for environmental issues and causes. Employees from Dr. Murad’s skincare company Murad, Inc. have joined us on numerous beach cleanups, as well as solidly supporting our efforts in curtailing marine debris.

You’re invited to join our celebration of these eco warriors on May 16, 2013 at the Jonathan Beach Club.